next up previous
Next: Expectation specifications Up: Introduction and motivation Previous: Why Bayes linear methods?

Establishing the example

Our example concerns the oral glucose tolerance test (ogt-test), used as an indicator of diabetes. The ogt-test is intended to measure the time taken to absorb a given quantity of sugar, with high values indicating diabetes. The test involves measuring the blood-glucose level in mmol/litre before and after a fixed quantity of sugar is taken orally (after fasting for twelve hours). Typically the blood glucose level is measured immediately prior to, and two hours after, the sugar is swallowed. Additionally, measurements might be made at intervening half-hour points. The most frequently utilised measurements are the fasting and two-hour measurements, taken before and two hours after ingestion of the sugar, and a well-established diagnosis of diabetes depends only upon these two measurements. Threshholds for the various diagnoses are given in figure 1.

  figure3874
Figure 1:  Oral glucose tolerance tests: diagnosis threshholds

We examine the efficacy of the ogt-test in relation to elderly people (for our purposes, people at least 60 years old). Previous trials of the ogt-test dealt largely with younger people, but there is a suspicion that the threshholds that indicate diabetes in a young person are inappropriate for older people. In particular, it is possible that the two-hour diagnosis threshhold is set too high for the elderly because their bodies react more slowly in general, and so take longer to absorb sugar. As a consequence, it is suspected that the ogt-test might often misdiagnose impaired glucose tolerance or diabetes in healthy elderly patients.

For our chosen scenario we suppose that an elderly lady doctor is interested in the adequacy of the test for older people, and that she decides to administer the ogt-test on herself to obtain further information. To help organise her thoughts, she writes down the quantities tex2html_wrap_inline8580 and tex2html_wrap_inline8582 , representing respectively the blood glucose levels measured before and two hours after swallowing the sugar. She thinks of each as a measurement on a randomly chosen elderly person, presumed healthy and non-diabetic. Corresponding to these quantities, she considers the measurements that she will make upon herself, and writes these down as tex2html_wrap_inline8546 and tex2html_wrap_inline8550 . Thus tex2html_wrap_inline8546 and tex2html_wrap_inline8550 are the (observable) before-and-after measurements that she makes on herself; whereas tex2html_wrap_inline8580 and tex2html_wrap_inline8582 are the (unobservable) before-and-after measurements for an elderly person picked at random. Our Doctor's aim is to learn about tex2html_wrap_inline8580 , tex2html_wrap_inline8582 , and various linear combinations such as tex2html_wrap_inline8600 , via tex2html_wrap_inline8546 and tex2html_wrap_inline8550 . Informally you might think of the former pair as characterising a typical member of the (elderly) population; and the latter pair as a ``sample'' from that population.

At this point we will introduce some notation. We only distinguish between collections of quantities, which we term bases, and the more formal organisation of such collections as vectors of quantities, when this is not clear from the context. Thus we will refer both to the bases

eqnarray442

and to the vectors tex2html_wrap_inline8606 and tex2html_wrap_inline8608 defined to be

displaymath8578

As we shall see, our approach allows us to obtain general impressions about collections of quantities as well as individual quantities, and when taking such a wider view we use the following notation:

The minimum specifications that we require for an analysis are expectations, variances and covariances over all the quantities of interest. If we intend (as we do) to produce adjusted expectations (informally, revisions) then we need some observations as well.




next up previous
Next: Expectation specifications Up: Introduction and motivation Previous: Why Bayes linear methods?

David Wooff
Thu Oct 15 12:20:04 BST 1998